Old Fashioned & Specialty Cakes

Two Fat Cats Bakery offers quality special occasion cakes in a variety of sizes and flavors and lovingly filled and decorated with a frosting of your choice. It is always best to order cakes in advance. We ask for a minimum of 48 hours notice to accommodate your cake needs and we do not take e-mail orders. However, because we know it is sometimes difficult to order in advance, we stock our display case with a number of cakes for your last minute needs.

Cake Sizes

ROUND

  • 6″ (6-8 servings)
  •  8″ (10-12 servings)
  • 10″ (16-20 servings)

RECTANGULAR

  • 1/4 sheet (20 servings)
  • 1/2 sheet (40 servings)

Cake Flavors

VANILLA CAKE with buttermilk, whole eggs, butter and real vanilla.
CHOCOLATE CAKE made with high-quality cocoa for a moist, deep chocolate taste.

Frosting & Fillings

BUTTERCREAM Available for vanilla and chocolate cakes. Choose from the following flavors.

Chocolate or Vanilla:

6″ – $19;  8″ – $30;  10″ – $42; 1/4 sheet – $43;  1/2 sheet – $74

Peanut Butter or Mocha:

6″ – $23;  8″ – $35;  10″ – $45; 1/4 sheet – $47; 1/2 sheet – $80

FILLING Add one of our fillings for $5 extra to create a truly unique cake. Flavors include Raspberry, Strawberry, Mixed Berry, or Blueberry

Specialty Cakes

RED VELVET A 1950s throwback that’s delicious in any decade. Choose a cream cheese or buttercream frosting.

6″ – $25.50;  8″ – $38.50;  10″ – $50.75;  1/4 sheet – $53; 1/2 sheet – $80

CARROT CAKE Three tiers of a moist cake filled with organic carrots, pecans and golden raisins topped with our classic cream cheese frosting.

6″ – $27.50;  8″ – $38.50;  10″ – $55;  1/4 sheet – $53; 1/2 sheet – $88

CHOCOLATE BLACKOUT CAKE An American classic from Brooklyn. Chocolate cake filled with dark chocolate pudding and covered in chocolate cookie crumbs.

6″ – $27.50;  8″ – $38.50

HOMEMADE COCONUT Three layers of our rich vanilla butter cake with a gooey coconut filling. Finished with a coconut buttercream and toasted coconut.

6″ – $27.50;  8″ – $38.50;  10″ – $55;  1/4 sheet – $57; 1/2 sheet – $88

FAT CAT LEMON An elegant vanilla butter cake filled with a homemade lemon curd and finished with our creamy lemon frosting.

6″ – $27.50;  8″ – $38.50;  10″ – $55;  1/4 sheet – $53; 1/2 sheet – $88

GERMAN CHOCOLATE Our classic chocolate cake with a thick coconut pecan filling and rich chocolate frosting.

6″ – $27.50;  8″ – $38.50;  10″ – $55;  1/4 sheet – $57; 1/2 sheet – $88

ALMOND DREAM It’s all about the almond from the frosting to the filling to the decoration of sliced almonds.

6″ – $27.50;  8″ – $38.50;  10″ – $55;  1/4 sheet – $57; 1/2 sheet – $88

MINT CHOCOLATE Think girl scout cookies gone wild. Too good for words.

6″ – $27.50;  8″ – $38.50;  10″ – $55;  1/4 sheet – $57; 1/2 sheet – $88

FRUIT & HONEY Local honey shines in this vanilla cake with alternating layers of seasonal fruit filling and vanilla pastry cream.

6″ – $27.50;  8″ – $38.50;  10″ – $55;  1/4 sheet – $57; 1/2 sheet – $88

Decorations

Our cake decorators are always willing and eager to make your cake extra special. Two Fat Cats Bakery offers some standard decorations and messages free of charge, but can also custom-design decorations for an additional fee. Please contact the bakery to discuss ideas and pricing. Prices vary depending on the intricacy of design.