At Two Fat Cats, we’re passionate about our pie making.  That’s why we never take shortcuts when making our pies.  Each and every pie we make is hand-rolled, filled with the highest quality ingredients and baked to perfection. It’s a pie you can be proud to serve at your table!

Small – 7″ $15.00 – $16.50
Large – 9″ $22.00- $25.00

(Special Order Pies require 48 hours notice.)

BLUEBERRY Maine blueberries are mixed with a bit of sugar & spice to create a pie you can only find in Maine!

MIXED BERRY Maine blueberries, raspberries & blackberries mingle in the ultimate pie for berry lovers.

SOUR CHERRY Made  with Michigan’s famous sour cherries, this is a vibrant and delicious pie.

BOURBON PECAN toasted pecans & bourbon combine for a pie that’s classic, but not too sweet.
CHOCOLATE CREAM Premium chocolate and thick cream make this a chocolate pie not to be missed!

COCONUT CREAM A delightful pie topped with shredded coconut
& whipped cream.

CHICKEN POT PIE Slow simmered chicken with pearl onions, peas, carrots, celery & gravy.

SEASONAL PIES Small, 7″ / Large, 9″
Two Fat Cats Bakery offers a variety of seasonal pies throughout Maine’s summer and fall.  Call the bakery to learn what’s in season.  Prices may vary.

APPLE Made with local Cortland & Macintosh apples, this is a pie that can stand on its own with or without ice cream

KEY LIME Key lime juice packs the punch that makes this classic a hit.

BLUEBERRY RHUBARB At Two Fat Cats, we love rhubarb.  This unique pie combines two of our favorite fruits, local blueberries & rhubarb.

STRAWBERRY RHUBARB Ruby red and delicious, don’t miss this pie during strawberry season!

PEACH freshly picked peaches with a little bit of sugar make for a wonderfully fresh-tasting pie.

RASPBERRY PEACH We couldn’t resist this combination.  If you’ve never tried this pie before, treat yourself!

PUMPKIN We use a light hand when it comes to the sugar in this pie to create a confection that tastes of autumn.