CAKES
Our cakes are rich, moist, & finished with a classic Italian buttercream. Our custom round layered cakes are made with 3 layers of cake with an optional filling, & frosting of your choice. Quarter Sheet & Half Sheet cakes are 2-layers with optional filling & choice of frosting. All custom cakes are made to order, so you can create your favorite flavor combination.
SIZES & SERVINGS
6″ (serves 6-8)
Note: 48-hour advanced ordering required
8″ (serves 10-12)
Note: 48-hour advanced ordering required
10″ (serves 16-20)
Note: 48-hour advanced ordering required
1/4 SHEET (serves 20)
Note: 5-business day advanced ordering required
1/2 SHEET (Serves 40)
Note: 5-business day advanced ordering required
CUSTOM CAKES
FLAVORS
Chocolate
Vanilla
Carrot
FILLINGS +
Chocolate Filling
Vanilla Filling
Pastry Cream*
Strawberry Filling*
Lemon Curd*
Raspberry Filling*
Chocolate Pastry Cream*
Caramel Filling*
FROSTINGS
Chocolate Frosting
Vanilla Buttercream
American Buttercream
Cream Cheese Frosting*
Coffee Buttercream*
Lemon Buttercream*
Honey Buttercream*
Almond Buttercream*
Oreo Frosting*
*Specialty Options +$
Made just for you
We can write simple messages on most cakes at no additional charge.
Looking for specialty or custom decorations?
Reach out and we’ll be happy to help.
For cake decoration inspo photos, please email them to us at info@twofatcatsbakery.com for approval before starting an order.
CAKES
Our signature specialty cakes are perfect for any occasion. No substitutions
or changes to specialty cakes; simple writing or decoration available.
Fat Cat Lemon
Carrot Cake
Black and White Cake
Layers of Van & Choc Cake, Vanilla or Chocolate Frosting
Vanilla Latte Cake
Vanilla Cake, Pastry Cream, Coffee Buttercream
Oreo Cake
Chocolate cake, Oreo Frosting
Fruit & Honey Cake
Chocolate Blackout Cake
Our Maine spin on this Brooklyn favorite with layered chocolate cake and homemade chocolate pudding covered in chocolate cake crumbs.
Available in 6” or 8” only.
Raspberry Almond Cake
Salted Caramel Cake
Chocolate Cake, Caramel Filling (Dulce de leche), Vanilla Buttercream, Caramel & Ganache drizzle garnish
Lemon and Raspberry Cake
Flourless Chocolate Cake (2 layers)
Flourless Cake, Chocolate Pastry Cream, Chocolate Frosting
Holidays & Weekend Specials
In addition to our custom & specialty cakes, we have seasonal, Holiday and Weekend Specials too!
Weekend Specials are available for local preorder with pickup days only on Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays. Holiday Specials are available for specific ordering & pickup dates. Check out our Local Preorder online menu and see what’s new for Nationwide Shipping powered by Goldbelly®!
Prices and availability are subject to change. All products are made in a facility that processes wheat, dairy, eggs, soy, peanuts, and tree nuts.